Hard to comment without knowing the scale of the problem. How many units? Cost to repair known issues? [You HAVE secured an engineer's report, right?]

Knowing the ratio of legal costs to repair costs [they rarely scale at the same rate], & how these expenses will amortize per apartment, can be important for making sound decisions.

Separately--why did the AG break off pursuit after accepting your case?

The press is a hard thing to "manage"; sometimes it's like letting a genie out of its bottle. Here's a current case where owners were sharply divided on that strategy...& a splinter group proceeded without accord [too soon to know how this story ends]:

http://ny.curbed.com/archives/2011/03/24/disgruntled_northside_piers_buyers_declare_war_on_toll_brothers.php

http://www.brownstoner.com/brownstoner/archives/2011/03/window_pains_at.php

Another key factor is whether the developer is out of the building, or still owns units [& is on your board].

More info, please...

> Join the conversation Comments (1)

Hi...so, if you can imagine the multiple structural issues in new construction...then those are the ones we have. These began shortly after the units began to sell..the sponsor, who was, I think, still on board for a bit of that, addressed some and then disappeared. The sponsor is no longer involved.

We did everything from engineers' reports to photographs...we provided the lawyer with every piece of proof we had...the AG worked with an internal engineer who, it was clear, had a bias toward the developer, and chose to identify a few issues. While we were pursuing our case, many other key structural elements began to decline...bad roof (also not insulated), flooding in basements because of the absence of proper plumbing and check valves (which we are installing now), broken pipes that have caused severe internal leaks, poor pointing on the brick that allows water to seep into the apartments, poorly installed wiring...the list goes on...

I think, though, the AG, once the sponsors did not respond to the subpoena, decided it was a lost cause. (We also thought it was against the law to not respond to the AG! Well, so much for justice!) We had public officials contact the AG's office.

And, personally, I think our high-end lawyer (who will remain nameless) took us for a bit of a ride.

So, now we are trying to catch up on our expenses while also tackling repairs. I feel like there is no oversight of developers...and if this is happening all over the city, why isn't there some activity around that ? I think I might have to organize a group.

Yes, the press issue is what you describe here...but we have a small complex...only 15 units...

Thx.

> Join the conversation Comments (1)

I understand your issue, we have one also. New construction, bad defective construction. Get the press involved, have the press call out the AG, and all agencies and developers, don't know if it will do much but getting a group together and pursuing that avenue on TV and other outlets will bring attention to others in the same position and hopefully embarrass all agencies including the AG for not taking a stand, including inspectors at the DOB.

> Join the conversation

It is a risk if anyone wants to sell a unit but perhaps if publized via a news story or in print the offending parties at least have respond. Also see if you can get NYC building inspectors involved - there may be violations the developers will be required to address. What is your management company doing - maybe consider a new company that has experience in this area. good luck

> Join the conversation